Queer Representation and Visibility in Doctor WhoThe Fat One and The Thin One

The Fat One and The Thin One are minor characters who appeared in the series six episode A Good Man Goes To War. They are two, of many, Anglican Marines stationed on the Demon’s Run base, charged with guarding Amy and Melody Pond. It is revealed to the audience that they are married shortly after their introduction, during an exchange with another Marine, Lorna Bucket

Thin One: Hello. I’m the Thin One. This is my husband. He’s the Fat One.
Lorna: Don’t you have names?
Fat One: We’re the Thin Fat Gay married Anglican Marines. Why would we need names as well?

Though they are only minor characters I have chosen to include them in this series because much of what is problematic about their portrayal helps shed light on the  bigger problems the show has had with GSM representation since Moffat has taken over as showrunner. 

Firstly their sexual orientations are sensationalised for a cheap laugh. I mean, let’s be clear, if these two had been a man and a women the fact that they were fat, thin, married, Anglican marines would not have been a joke. This isn’t the only time sexual orientations are used for a punchline. It is something which happens over and over again, with Madame Vastra and Jenny, Canton, River and Captain Jack during his first appearance. 

This choice to constantly play GSM character’s sexual orientations for laughs is grossly offensive and a complete double standard that, as I’ve mentioned before, facilitates the othering of GSM folk and reinforces attitudes and opinions which are used to justify all kinds of oppressive behavior. 

Furthermore, with regards to these two specifically, the implication that their sexual orientations would be enough to differentiate them from every other marine on that base makes no sense. The Battle of Demon’s Run takes place in the 52nd century, a time where same-gender and inter-species relationship are, supposedly, commonplace. 

To top it all off, shortly after the above exchange, The Fat One is taken to the Headless Monks headquaters where he believes he is going to participate in a conversion tutorial, but is actually murdered. 

Whilst Moffat appears to want to improve the representation of GSM folk in Doctor Who he continuously turns these characters orientations into jokes. The Fat One and The Thin One encapsulate this tendency in a very revealing way. Whilst some people may be of the opinion that their presence, as visible gay characters, is valuable in and of itself, I personally feel that characters like The Fat One and The Thin One are far more harmful than they are helpful. Rather than have more characters such as these two, It’d be far better to see a return to GSM characters whose orientations are normalised and not reduced to one-liners and comedic relief. 

Queer Representation and Visibility in Doctor WhoThe Fat One and The Thin One

The Fat One and The Thin One are minor characters who appeared in the series six episode A Good Man Goes To War. They are two, of many, Anglican Marines stationed on the Demon’s Run base, charged with guarding Amy and Melody Pond. It is revealed to the audience that they are married shortly after their introduction, during an exchange with another Marine, Lorna Bucket

Thin One: Hello. I’m the Thin One. This is my husband. He’s the Fat One.
Lorna: Don’t you have names?
Fat One: We’re the Thin Fat Gay married Anglican Marines. Why would we need names as well?

Though they are only minor characters I have chosen to include them in this series because much of what is problematic about their portrayal helps shed light on the  bigger problems the show has had with GSM representation since Moffat has taken over as showrunner. 

Firstly their sexual orientations are sensationalised for a cheap laugh. I mean, let’s be clear, if these two had been a man and a women the fact that they were fat, thin, married, Anglican marines would not have been a joke. This isn’t the only time sexual orientations are used for a punchline. It is something which happens over and over again, with Madame Vastra and Jenny, Canton, River and Captain Jack during his first appearance. 

This choice to constantly play GSM character’s sexual orientations for laughs is grossly offensive and a complete double standard that, as I’ve mentioned before, facilitates the othering of GSM folk and reinforces attitudes and opinions which are used to justify all kinds of oppressive behavior. 

Furthermore, with regards to these two specifically, the implication that their sexual orientations would be enough to differentiate them from every other marine on that base makes no sense. The Battle of Demon’s Run takes place in the 52nd century, a time where same-gender and inter-species relationship are, supposedly, commonplace. 

To top it all off, shortly after the above exchange, The Fat One is taken to the Headless Monks headquaters where he believes he is going to participate in a conversion tutorial, but is actually murdered. 

Whilst Moffat appears to want to improve the representation of GSM folk in Doctor Who he continuously turns these characters orientations into jokes. The Fat One and The Thin One encapsulate this tendency in a very revealing way. Whilst some people may be of the opinion that their presence, as visible gay characters, is valuable in and of itself, I personally feel that characters like The Fat One and The Thin One are far more harmful than they are helpful. Rather than have more characters such as these two, It’d be far better to see a return to GSM characters whose orientations are normalised and not reduced to one-liners and comedic relief. 

Posted on 17 June 2012
Tags: #Queer Representation and Visibility in Doctor Who  #a good man goes to war  #The Fat One  #The Thin One  
  1. thebestjonathan reblogged this from penguintim
  2. joey-hazell reblogged this from gunpowderandspark
  3. punkassbuckybarnes reblogged this from penguintim
  4. sugarbowlcode reblogged this from penguintim
  5. dralokyn reblogged this from spaceywaceygracey
  6. spaceywaceygracey reblogged this from gunpowderandspark
  7. gunpowderandspark reblogged this from penguintim
  8. canadianunicorn reblogged this from penguintim and added:
    #dw #doctor who #moffat
  9. anangryhamster reblogged this from penguintim
  10. something-i-dunno reblogged this from penguintim
  11. soufflemenace reblogged this from penguintim
  12. adricthemindnimon reblogged this from penguintim
  13. schrodingersdeal reblogged this from penguintim
  14. penguintim reblogged this from feministwhoniverse
  15. hatssherlockhappiness reblogged this from feministwhoniverse
  16. justifiedcandy reblogged this from feministwhoniverse
  17. kavto-m reblogged this from feministwhoniverse
  18. retrogradewaters reblogged this from calliatra and added:
    I was worried about these two as soon as they appeared, and I was right. Not because the characters were harmful (being...
  19. calliatra reblogged this from feministwhoniverse
  20. comedanceintherain reblogged this from feministwhoniverse
  21. acivilmuffin reblogged this from rhodesstark
  22. raynargayez-jr reblogged this from rhodesstark
  23. rhodesstark reblogged this from jon-snow
  24. principia-coh reblogged this from ginamak
  25. thursdaysoldier reblogged this from ihavealittlefeminism
  26. willgrahamisautistic reblogged this from ladysaviours
  27. ladysaviours reblogged this from feministcharacters
  28. eraofstories reblogged this from extoria
  29. theregeneratinggeneration reblogged this from extoria
  30. extoria reblogged this from jon-snow